Launch our birth injury Special Investigation Unit

call to see if medical negligence caused the injury.

 

1-800-708-5433

 

 

The First 72 Hours After a Suspected Birth Injury

What to document, what to ask, and how to protect your child’s future without feeling overwhelmed

When a birth becomes complicated—an emergency C-section, shoulder dystocia, an unexpected NICU transfer, concerns about oxygen deprivation, seizures, or a newborn who “isn’t acting right”—the first hours can feel unreal. You may be exhausted, scared, and suddenly expected to understand medical language you’ve never heard before.

 

If you’re here because something doesn’t sit right about what happened before, during, or right after delivery, you’re not alone. Many parents describe the same experience: confusion in the moment, followed by unanswered questions later.

This guide is written for families facing a possible birth injury. It’s meant to be accurate, practical, and compassionate—so you can stay focused on your baby’s care while preserving the information that often matters most for medical follow-up and, when appropriate, a birth injury claim.

 

This article provides general information, not medical advice or legal advice. If you need urgent medical guidance, follow your clinical team’s instructions or seek emergency care.

 

 

Why the first 72 hours matter

The first three days are when:

• Major medical decisions are made (NICU monitoring, seizure evaluation, imaging, and sometimes therapeutic hypothermia (cooling) when a baby meets specific clinical criteria).

• Some of the most important documentation is created (fetal monitoring, delivery notes, newborn resuscitation records, cord blood gas results).

• Your memory is freshest—even though stress can make the timeline feel like a blur.

• Early signs may emerge that guide follow-up care (neurology, therapy referrals, developmental monitoring).

You do not need to “build a case” in the hospital. But you can take calm, respectful steps to protect your baby and preserve the truth.

 

 

Step 1: Get a “notes person” if you can

If you have a partner, family member, or trusted friend with you, give them one job: Be your notes person.

 

Their role is simple: write down times, names, questions, and answers—while you focus on your baby and your own recovery. If you’re alone, a phone notes app works. Short entries are enough.

 

 

Step 2: Start a simple timeline

Open a note and title it:

Labor + Delivery Timeline

Then record:

• Approximate time

• What happened (plain language)

• Who said it (name + role if possible)

• What you observed

Examples:

• “1:40 pm — nurse said baby’s heart rate dropped; repositioned me.”

• “2:10 pm — doctor discussed C-section; said we could keep trying a little longer.”

• “3:28 pm — baby delivered; NICU team present; baby didn’t cry right away.”

• “4:05 pm — told baby going to NICU; concern for seizures mentioned.”

Why this matters: later, specialists and reviewers often need the sequence of events. A timeline helps you preserve it while it’s still fresh.

 

 

Step 3: Ask these questions (even if you feel intimidated)

You are allowed to ask direct questions. If someone is rushed, ask who can return later to explain.

Questions about your baby right now

• What is the working diagnosis right now?

• What are the main concerns being monitored (breathing, seizures, feeding, infection, oxygen levels)?

• Has the baby shown signs of seizures or abnormal movements?

• Is there concern about HIE (hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy) or encephalopathy?

• What tests have been ordered (EEG, labs, imaging), and when will we have results?

Questions about what happened during labor and delivery

• When did the team first become concerned about the baby’s status?

• What did the fetal monitoring show, in plain language?

• Was there discussion about expediting delivery sooner (C-section, vacuum, forceps)?

• If there was a delay, what was the reason?

Questions about the next 12–24 hours

• What is the plan for the next day?

• What complications are being watched for?

• What changes should we report immediately?

• Who is the attending physician responsible for decisions right now?

A helpful sentence if you’re overwhelmed:
“Can you explain that to me like I’m hearing it for the first time?”

 

 

Step 4: If you hear these terms, pause and ask for a plain-English explanation

In complicated births, families often hear medical shorthand before they get a clear explanation. If you hear any of the terms below, ask:

“What does that mean for our baby, specifically?”

Common terms that may come up in suspected birth injury situations:

• Non-reassuring fetal heart tracing

• Late decelerations, minimal variability

• Category II or Category III strip

• Meconium

• Shoulder dystocia (often associated with brachial plexus injuries like Erb’s palsy)

• Vacuum delivery or forceps delivery

• Low Apgar scores

• Cord blood gas, pH, base deficit

• HIE

• Cooling therapy (therapeutic hypothermia)

• Seizures, EEG

• MRI timing

Important: a term by itself does not prove malpractice and does not predict your child’s outcome. What matters is the full picture—especially the timeline and objective records.

 

 

Step 5: Document what you can without interfering with care

You can preserve helpful information while still keeping everything respectful and calm.

Save and photograph paperwork

If hospital policy allows, photograph:

• Discharge instructions

• Medication lists

• NICU handouts

• Appointment sheets and referral forms

• Any printed test results the team gives you

Write down names and roles

Create a running list:

• Attending OB or midwife

• Labor and delivery nurses

• Neonatologist

• NICU nurses

• Neurology consult (if one occurs)

• Anyone who communicates a serious concern or diagnosis

Be careful with recordings

Policies and laws vary by location and hospital. If you’re thinking about audio or video recording, ask about the hospital’s policy first. Written notes and formal medical records requests are usually the safest, most useful path.

 

 

Step 6: Understand what records will exist

Birth injury questions are record-driven. If a child later receives diagnoses such as cerebral palsy, developmental delay, seizure disorder, or brachial plexus injury, the “why” is often found in records created during:

• Labor (fetal monitoring strips, nursing notes, medication charting, responses to concerning tracings)

• Delivery (operative report, shoulder dystocia documentation, vacuum/forceps notes, timing details)

• Newborn transition (resuscitation record, Apgars, cord blood gases)

• NICU care (neurology notes, EEG findings, imaging, and any specialized protocols used)

Requesting records is common and does not automatically mean you’re accusing anyone. It is one of the most practical ways to protect your child’s future.

 

 

Step 7: Before you leave the hospital, request these essentials

You may not receive everything immediately, but you can often leave with key summaries and a clear path to request the complete chart.

Records to request for your baby

• Newborn discharge summary (or NICU discharge summary)

• Consult notes (neonatology, neurology, others if involved)

• EEG report (if performed)

• Imaging reports (head ultrasound/MRI), if performed

• Medication list and diagnoses used during admission (including “rule-out” diagnoses)

• Follow-up plan and referrals (neurology, developmental pediatrics, therapy, early intervention)

Records to request for the mother

• Labor and delivery discharge summary

• Operative report if C-section

• Anesthesia summary if available

• Documentation of complications (infection, hemorrhage, blood pressure issues, etc.)

One important question to ask before discharge:
“How do we request the complete medical record later, including any available fetal monitoring tracings/strips (or documentation if intermittent monitoring was used)?”

 

 

Step 8: Don’t delay early support if something feels off

Even when the cause is unclear, early evaluation and therapy can be important. If you notice:

• stiffness or unusual floppiness

• feeding difficulty, choking, or fatigue with feeding

• abnormal movements or suspected seizures

• one-sided weakness

• an arm that doesn’t move normally (possible brachial plexus injury)

• delayed milestones over the coming months

These signs can have many causes, but they deserve timely evaluation.

Ask your pediatrician about:

• Early intervention referral

• PT/OT evaluation

• Feeding therapy if appropriate

• Neurology follow-up when indicated

You are not being dramatic. You are being protective.

 

 

When families consider a legal review, and why it can help

Many parents hesitate to ask legal questions, especially while their baby is still receiving care. That hesitation is understandable. But families seek answers for practical reasons:

• To understand what happened and when

• To plan for future care needs

• To secure resources when a preventable injury changes a child’s life

• To hold systems accountable and improve safety

Every case turns on medical facts, the timeline, and whether care met the applicable standard of care.

A careful birth injury review is typically focused on the medical record and the timeline, including:

• Fetal monitoring interpretation and response

• Whether warning signs were recognized and escalated appropriately

• Timeliness of delivery decisions, including when a C-section was discussed and performed

• Management of delivery emergencies such as shoulder dystocia

• Use of vacuum or forceps and whether criteria and limits were followed

• Newborn resuscitation decisions and NICU management

• Whether earlier intervention likely would have changed the outcome

The goal is not blame for the sake of blame. The goal is clarity—and, when appropriate, justice and resources for a child’s lifelong needs.

 

 

How BirthLaw.com can help

If you suspect a preventable birth injury, you deserve clear answers—not vague explanations.

Our birth injury team at BirthLaw.com can help you:

• Understand which records matter and how to request them

• Make sense of terms like HIE, fetal distress, shoulder dystocia, cord blood gas results, EEG, and MRI reports

• Identify the timeline questions that often determine preventability

• Evaluate whether compensation may be available to support therapy, equipment, home modifications, and long-term care

If you want a confidential conversation about what happened, contact our birth injury attorneys at BirthLaw.com. We can listen to what you remember, help you understand the next steps, and explain what a careful, record-driven review looks like.

If you’re not ready to talk yet, start here:

1. Create your timeline note today

2. Save every discharge and NICU document in one folder

3. Ask the hospital how to request the complete record, including fetal monitoring tracings/strips

When you’re ready, our team can help you take the next step at a pace that feels right.

 

 

A gentle reminder for parents reading this

You didn’t cause this by asking questions.
You are not “too emotional” to understand.
You are allowed to seek clarity—especially when your child’s future is on the line.

If something feels unanswered, trust that instinct. Clarity matters.

 

 

Frequently asked questions

What should I document if I think my baby suffered a birth injury?

Start a simple timeline with approximate times, what happened, who said what, and what you observed. Save discharge and NICU paperwork, and write down the names and roles of key clinicians.

Can low Apgar scores prove a birth injury?

Not by themselves. Apgar scores describe how a baby is transitioning immediately after birth. Other information—such as cord blood gases, neurologic findings, EEG results, and imaging—often provides more meaningful context.

What records matter most in a birth injury case?

Records commonly reviewed include fetal monitoring tracings/strips (if used), nursing notes, delivery and operative notes, cord blood gas results, newborn resuscitation records, NICU notes, EEG reports, and imaging reports.

Should I request medical records before talking to a birth injury lawyer?

You can, but you don’t have to. Many families talk first so they know exactly what to request and how to request it correctly, including any available fetal monitoring tracings/strips and key NICU documentation.

Is it too soon to talk to a birth injury lawyer while my baby is still in the NICU?

It can be appropriate to talk early, especially if you want guidance on preserving records and understanding next steps. A reputable firm will prioritize your child’s care and proceed at a pace that feels right for your family.